The following examples illustrate the proposed operation of the new rules compared with the current regime. All examples assume: the taxpayer is an individual; the marginal tax rate is 47% (top marginal rate including Medicare levy) unless otherwise stated; inflation (CPI uplift) is 3% per annum on a compound basis unless otherwise stated; all assets are held for >12 months; and the new rules commence on 1 July 2027.
Example 1: Shares acquired after CGT - individual (top marginal rate)
Facts: David purchased shares in a listed company on 1 July 2020 for $100,000. He sells them on 30 June 2030 for $300,000.
The total gain of $200,000 must be split between pre-2027 and post-2027 components.
- Using valuation method: market value on 1 July 2027 = $190,000 (determined from exchange records)
- Pre-2027 gain = $190,000 − $100,000 = $90,000; After 50% discount = $45,000 assessable
- Post-2027 gain = $300,000 − $190,000 = $110,000; Indexed cost base (3% CPI for 3 years) = $190,000 × 1.093 = $207,670; Gain after indexation = $300,000 − $207,670 = $92,330
Under the old rules, the 50% discount applied to the entire gain ($200,000 → $100,000 assessable), and David at 47% marginal rate would have paid $47,000.
The new result is $64,545 - approximately 37% more tax. The minimum tax does not bite here since David's marginal rate (47%) exceeds 30%.
Example 2: Pre-CGT asset - family farm sold after 1 July 2027
Facts: The Henderson family purchased a rural property in March 1982 for $80,000 (a pre-CGT asset). At 1 July 2027, the property is worth $2.5 million. They sell it on 30 June 2029 for $2.8 million. Their marginal tax rate is 47%.
Under current rules, the entire gain is exempt (pre-CGT asset). Under the new rules:
- Gains to 1 July 2027 (i.e., the $2.5 million appreciation from $80,000) remain permanently exempt
- Deemed cost base at 1 July 2027 = $2,500,000 (market value)
- Post-2027 gain = $2,800,000 − $2,500,000 = $300,000
- Indexed cost base (3% CPI × 2 years) = $2,500,000 × 1.061 = $2,652,500
- Since sale price ($2.8M) > indexed cost base ($2.65M): taxable gain = $2,800,000 − $2,652,500 = $147,500
Item
| Current Rules
| New Rules (from 1 Jul 2027)
|
Original purchase price (1982)
| $80,000
| $80,000
|
Market value at 1 July 2027
| N/A
| $2,500,000
|
Sale proceeds (30 June 2029)
| $2,800,000
| $2,800,000
|
Gain exempt (pre-CGT / pre-2027 gain)
| Full $2,720,000 exempt
| $2,420,000 exempt (pre-2027)
|
Post-2027 gross gain
| N/A
| $300,000
|
Indexed cost base uplift (3% CPI × 2yr)
| N/A
| $2,652,500
|
Taxable gain after indexation
| $0
| $147,500
|
Tax at 47% marginal rate
| $0
| $69,325
|
Minimum tax check (30% × $147,500 = $44,250)
| N/A
| Marginal rate applies ($69,325 > $44,250)
|
TOTAL TAX
| $0
| $69,325
|
Key takeaway: The family pays no tax on 40+ years of appreciation (the pre-2027 gain). But the 2-year post-2027 appreciation of $300,000 is substantially taxed. If the family had sold before 1 July 2027, the entire $2.72 million gain would have been exempt - a tax saving of $69,325 compared to waiting.
The family may be eligible for the Small Business CGT Exemptions, which could reduce the capital gain potentially to NIL.
Example 3: Retiree with low income - minimum tax in action
Facts: Sally retired in July 2027. She holds shares purchased in December 2019 for $50,000, worth $120,000 on 1 July 2027. She sells them in June 2028 for $135,000. Her only other income is $2,000 of interest. Assume 2% CPI in the one year from 1 July 2027 to sale.
- Pre-2027 gain = $120,000 − $50,000 = $70,000; After 50% discount = $35,000 assessable
- Post-2027 gross gain = $135,000 − $120,000 = $15,000
- Indexed cost base (2% CPI × 1 year) = $120,000 × 1.02 = $122,400
- Post-2027 gain after indexation = $135,000 − $122,400 = $12,600
- Total assessable income = $2,000 (interest) + $35,000 (pre-2027 CGT) + $12,600 (post-2027 CGT) = $49,600
Item
| Current Rules
| New Rules (from 1 Jul 2027)
|
Pre-2027 gain (50% discount applies)
| $42,500 assessable
| $35,000 assessable
|
Post-2027 gain after indexation
| N/A
| $12,600
|
Other income (interest)
| $2,000
| $2,000
|
Total assessable income
| $44,500 (no CGT split)
| $49,600
|
Tax at marginal rates on total income
| $3,682
| $5,132 |
30% minimum tax on post-2027 gain: 30% × $12,600
| N/A
| $3,780
|
Effective rate on $12,600 from marginal rates
| N/A
| $2,500 |
Minimum tax top-up: $3,780
| N/A
| $1,280 additional tax payable |
TOTAL TAX (all components)
| $3,682
| $6,412 |
Key takeaway: This example demonstrates the minimum tax in action. As Sally’s marginal rate on part of the post-2027 gain is below 30%, the minimum tax applies and requires a top-up payment.
This provision is designed to ensure retirees with low income cannot use the low-rate benefit to shelter post-2027 capital gains below the 30% floor.
Example 4: start-up founder - indexation vs 50% discount
Facts: James founded a technology company in 2021, acquiring his shares for $10,000 (nominal cost). He sells 100% of his shares on 30 June 2031 for $5,000,000. Value at 1 July 2027 (per independent valuation) = $1,200,000. CPI increases 3% p.a. for the 4 years post-2027.
- Pre-2027 gain = $1,200,000 − $10,000 = $1,190,000; After 50% discount = $595,000 assessable
- Post-2027 gross gain = $5,000,000 − $1,200,000 = $3,800,000
- Indexed cost base (3% × 4 yrs compound) = $1,200,000 × 1.126 = $1,351,200
- Post-2027 taxable gain = $5,000,000 − $1,351,200 = $3,648,800
- Under the old rules (no split): 50% discount on full gain → $2,495,000 assessable
Item
| Current Rules
| New Rules (from 1 Jul 2027)
|
Purchase price
| $10,000
| $10,000
|
Sale proceeds
| $5,000,000
| $5,000,000
|
Total gross gain
| $4,990,000
| $4,990,000
|
Total assessable (old: 50% of full gain)
| $2,495,000
| N/A
|
Pre-2027 assessable (50% × $1,190,000)
| N/A
| $595,000
|
Post-2027 indexed gain ($3,800,000 − $150,600 indexation)
| N/A
| $3,648,800
|
Total assessable income (new regime)
| $2,495,000
| $4,243,800
|
Tax at 47% marginal rate
| $1,172,650
| $1,994,568
|
Minimum tax (30% × $3,649,400 = $1,094,820)
| N/A
| Marginal rate ($1,994,568) exceeds 30%
|
TOTAL TAX
| $1,172,650
| $1,994,568
|
Additional tax under new regime
| —
| +$821,936 (70% more tax)
|
Key takeaway: Start-up founders are among the biggest losers under the new regime. The extremely low cost base means indexation provides minimal benefit, while the pre-2027 50% discount on the 'cheap' shares still applies. The dramatic increase in tax liability explains why the Government has flagged consultation with the tech and start-up sector on potential targeted concessions.
Example 5: post-2027 asset - indexation vs old discount
Facts: Maria purchases an investment property (established, not new build) on 1 August 2027 for $800,000 and sells it on 31 July 2034 (7 years later) for $1,200,000. CPI: 3% p.a. compound. Maria's marginal rate: 47%.
This asset was acquired after 1 July 2027, so the new regime applies in full. No transitional split is required.
- Gross gain = $1,200,000 − $800,000 = $400,000
- Indexed cost base (3% × 7 yrs compound) = $800,000 × 1.230 = $984,000
- Taxable gain after indexation = $1,200,000 − $984,000 = $216,000
- Under old rules: 50% discount → $200,000 assessable
Item
| Current Rules
| Proposed Rules from 1 July 2027
|
Purchase price
| $800,000
| $800,000
|
Sale proceeds
| $1,200,000
| $1,200,000
|
Gross capital gain
| $400,000
| $400,000
|
CGT adjustment
| 50% CGT discount applied → $200,000 assessable gain
| Indexed cost base of $984,000 → $216,000 assessable gain
|
Tax at 47% marginal rate
| $94,000
| $101,520
|
30% minimum tax check
| Not applicable
| Marginal tax exceeds 30% minimum tax threshold
|
Total tax payable
| $94,000
| $101,520
|
Difference
| —
| +$7,520 (approximately 8% higher)
|
Key takeaway: At moderate inflation (3%) and a 7-year hold, indexation is broadly comparable to (but slightly worse than) the 50% discount for this level of return. However, if inflation were to be higher (say 5%) the indexed cost base would be 1.407 x $1,200,000 = $1,125,600 and the taxable gain would be only $74,400 - resulting in much lower tax than the old rules. The new regime genuinely rewards long-term holding in high-inflation environments.